In distribution center operations, conversations about labor costs often start and stop with hourly rates. But the real ROI of managed warehouse labor extends far beyond what’s printed on a paycheck. When you account for productivity, safety, turnover, and throughput efficiency, the value equation changes entirely.
This article breaks down how to calculate true ROI from managed labor partnerships—and why focusing only on hourly rates leaves money on the dock.
Many operations leaders assume that if in-house associates earn $18/hour and managed labor charges $20/hour, outsourcing is more expensive. But that view ignores hidden costs that chip away at operational profitability:
When these hidden costs are factored in, managed labor’s value becomes measurable—and compelling.
ROI (%) = [(Total Savings − Cost of Managed Labor) ÷ Cost of Managed Labor] × 100
Add together:
Managed labor programs often increase throughput by 10–15% through structured accountability, incentive pay, and onsite leadership.
Example:
If a DC ships 2 million cases annually at $0.85 cost per case, a 10% productivity gain reduces cost-per-case to $0.77.
→ Savings: $160,000 per year.
Reducing turnover from 40% to 25% in a 200-associate operation saves:
15% × 200 × $5,000 = $150,000 annually.
If incident rate drops by just one OSHA recordable (avg. $42,000 per incident), the savings add up quickly.
Total Estimated Annual ROI Example:
| Category | Annual Savings |
|---|---|
| Productivity Uplift | $160,000 |
| Turnover Reduction | $150,000 |
| Safety Improvement | $42,000 |
| Total ROI Impact | $352,000 |
If managed labor costs $250,000 annually, the ROI = (352,000 − 250,000) / 250,000 × 100 = 40.8% ROI.
CFOs and operations leaders benefit from ROI models because they:
According to Gartner’s 2025 Supply Chain Finance Report, organizations that adopt outcome-based labor models achieve up to 12% lower overall cost-per-case year over year.
Beyond quantifiable ROI, managed labor creates intangible benefits that strengthen long-term performance:
Q1: What’s the average ROI for managed warehouse labor programs?
Most range from 25% to 45% annual ROI depending on facility size and baseline performance.
Q2: How fast can ROI be realized?
Typically within the first 90–120 days as productivity and turnover metrics stabilize.
Q3: Does managed labor always cost more per hour?
Not necessarily. Even when hourly rates are higher, cost-per-case and overall labor costs decline due to efficiency gains.
Q4: How can ROI be presented to finance teams?
Translate improvements in cases per hour, turnover, and injury reduction into cost-per-case savings.
Q5: What KPIs best reflect ROI?
Cost per case, cases per hour, turnover rate, and OSHA recordable rate.
👇📅 We're here to help. There's no pitch - just a conversation. 📅👇
If you need dependable support to reinforce your team and get you back on track, FHI NOW can help.
In any market, your supply chain can make or break your ability to compete well. Don't leave that to chance. We can help you create a stronger operation, so you never fall behind the competition.
Stop worrying about labor challenges and start enjoying a safe, lean, and rock-solid supply chain.
(800) 849-3132 | © FHI. All rights reserved.