How to Tell If Your Warehouse Labor Model Is the Problem (Not Your People)

When warehouse performance starts slipping, the first instinct is often to look at staffing.

Are people showing up?

Are they trained well enough?

Do we need more headcount?

But in many distribution centers, the real issue isn’t the workforce—it’s the labor model surrounding them.

This article helps operations leaders answer a critical question: Is your warehouse struggling because of people—or because of how labor is being managed?

Why do good warehouse teams still struggle?

One of the clearest signals that a labor model may be the issue is when capable, motivated teams still can’t produce consistent results.

Common symptoms include:

• Productivity varying widely by shift
• Supervisors constantly reallocating labor mid-shift
• Overtime becoming routine instead of seasonal
• Strong associates burning out
• Performance improving briefly, then slipping again

When effort is high but outcomes are inconsistent, the system—not the people—is often the constraint.

What is the difference between a people problem and a labor model problem?

A people problem usually shows up as:

• Chronic attendance issues
• Safety violations tied to individual behavior
• Refusal to follow processes

A labor model problem shows up as:

• Unclear productivity expectations
• Labor planned by schedule instead of workload
• Inconsistent supervision across shifts
• Limited visibility into real-time performance
• Too much reliance on overtime to “catch up”

Most warehouses experience a mix—but persistent operational issues usually point to the model.

What are the warning signs your labor model isn’t working?

Warehouses often miss early indicators because they feel “normal.”

Common warning signs include:

• Adding headcount doesn’t improve throughput
• One shift consistently outperforms others
• Supervisors spend more time reacting than leading
• Labor costs feel unpredictable month to month
• Service levels fluctuate even when volume is steady

These signals suggest misalignment between labor, workload, and accountability.

Why doesn’t hiring more people fix the problem?

When the labor model is flawed, adding people often increases complexity.

Without clear standards and visibility:

• New hires struggle to ramp up
• Productivity ceilings remain low
• Supervision becomes stretched
• Errors and rework increase

This is why many warehouses feel more stressed after staffing up—even though headcount increases.

How does labor visibility affect warehouse performance?

Visibility is one of the most overlooked elements of labor management.

When leaders lack real-time insight into:

• Productivity by function
• Performance by shift
• Labor allocation vs. volume

They’re forced to manage reactively.

Strong labor models give supervisors the ability to course-correct during the shift—not after problems have already occurred.

When should leaders rethink their warehouse labor model?

It’s time to reassess the labor model when:

• The same problems repeat quarter after quarter
• Peak seasons feel harder every year
• Overtime becomes the default solution
• Supervisors feel overwhelmed
• Growth creates instability instead of momentum

These are signals that the operation has outgrown its current approach to labor.

What does a healthier warehouse labor model look like?

Effective labor models tend to share a few traits:

• Clear productivity expectations
• Alignment between labor and daily demand
• Consistent leadership across shifts
• Accountability without micromanagement
• Visibility into performance and cost

The goal isn’t perfection—it’s predictability and control.

Common Questions About Warehouse Labor Models

How do I know if my warehouse has a labor model problem?

If performance issues persist despite capable teams and adequate staffing, the labor model is likely the issue.

Can a labor model really affect morale?

Yes. Unclear expectations and constant firefighting lead to burnout—even among strong performers.

Why does overtime keep increasing?

Overtime often masks planning and productivity gaps rather than solving them.

Is this more common in large warehouses?

Yes, but any operation experiencing growth or variability can outgrow its labor model.

When is the best time to make changes?

Before peak demand returns—when leaders have space to act proactively.

👇📅 We're here to help.  There's no pitch - just a conversation. 📅👇